Monday 8 April 2013

Introduction: Drum roll please.


Mechanical analysis of a basketball free throw




     Basketball is one of the world's most popular and widely viewed sports out there. Since basketball does not require a lot of equipment to play, it is often the most popular sport to start. All it requires is a basketball hoop, gym shorts and a ball. Also, basketball can be played indoors and outdoors which makes the sport playable in every season. Compared to sports like skiing where it is only possible in the winter season. Basketball is a team sport but can also be played by yourself. One important factor that can decide which team will win or lose is the free throw shot. A free throw shot is essential in basketball because the bio-mechanics is used throughout the sport. Take for example a jump shot, it takes its form from the free throw shot but instead you are in motion and suddenly stop to jump and release the ball. Even though free throw shooting looks fairly easy without a defender or time clock, the National Basketball Association has a rough average of only 75% success rate in the past 50 years. (Branch, J. (2009) For Free Throws, 50 Years of Practice is No Help. Online, The New York Times). One of the articles we use, concludes that the shooter should release the ball at an optimal angle that minimizes the speed of the ball coming off the hand, and attempt to maximize the backspin on the ball. (Brancazio, P.J. (1979) Physics of basketball. Am J Phys., 49(4), 356-365). The act of a free throw differs from each individual motion and also uses different joints of the body for the movement. By examining body movements of skilled shooters by Hudson*, he concluded that the most important factors are stability and ratio of release height to standing height. (Hudson, J.L. (1982) A biomechanical analysis by skill level of free throw shooting in basketball. In: Biomechanics in Sports. J. Terauds (Ed.), Del Mar, CA: Academic Publishers. 95-102). The free throw shot is a complex movement involving coordination of numerous joints throughout the body.

This project is intended to focus on the bio-mechanical analysis of a basketball free throw shot by using an experiment from an article that uses players of any experience to attempt a free throw shot. At the same time, the researchers are able to come to a percentage based on the way the players shoot the ball and if they miss or not. Our goal is to identify why most players have a specific bio-mechanic pattern throughout the free throw.


I'm lost... Might need some direction help.

Methods


To find out how to successfully score a free throw when being put at the foul shot line, we turn to one of the most powerful weapon made available to any university students when writing a research project: Google.

Honestly, Google turned out to be more troublesome than we could imagine. Many useless articles that popped up during our search did not offer the information we needed to analyze the free throw effectively. On top of those unused articles, many other random internet ad services selling body building or training programs also popped up.

However, through intensive research on the web, there were some article that caught our eyes. We managed to find some articles that focused on the whole movement of the body during the free throw shot, along with other factors that could possibly affect shooter's successful shot.

For example, some of the articles we found explained the detail positioning of the body during the free throw; from the behaviours before conducting the free throw, to the ball's movement in the air after the free throw were made.

Processing Information: Please hold.

Results


    Many people think free throw is just a simple throwing of the basketball at the hoop from the foul line. However, after analyzing numerous articles, we find that free throws actually take into account many different factors. Many different areas of skills like body movements, positioning and mental preparation for the shooter are involved from the moment the shooter walks up to the foul shot line to the moment the ball enters the rim.

    From the study at Pennsylvania State University, it seems that the angular velocity differs between shooters. However, the joints below the shoulder are generally all lower in terms of velocity when compared to the wrist and elbow. On top of that, the peak angular velocities was much higher for the upper body joints like the wrist and the elbow when compared to those of hip, knee, and the ankle (Martin, n.d.).

    In terms of joint movement patterns, there was not a whole lot of differences between the angle of the joint at the point where the ball is released and the success rate of the ball being scored (Martin, n.d.). But some major dissimilarities did pop out that could possibly determine the scoring of the basketball. One of such dissimilarity was that of the peak angular velocity of the joints involved for the free throw. For those who made the shot, their lower body joints, which are the hip, knee and the ankle had a much higher peak angular velocity when compared to the one that misses the shot. On the other hand, successful shooter's upper body joints, which are elbow and the wrists, had lower peak angular velocity than those who misses the shot (Martin, n.d.). On top of that, joints that are more proximal to the centre of the body were used first when compared to the distal joints of the body for those who made the shot. In another way, the movement spread from the centre of the body and moves through the hip, knee and the ankle for the lower body, while for the upper body, the movement spread from the centre of the body and moves through the shoulder, the elbow and then finally the wrist (Martin, n.d.).


    In whole, the joint movement pattern between the best and worst free throw shooters had much differences. One of which was that the joint motion and release angle for the best shooter was lower and changed less. The best shooter had also much more controlled and consistent joint velocity when making the shot; their peak elbow and body angular velocity were much lower than those of the worst shooter (Martin, n.d.). On top of that, the advanced shooters also go through a set order of joint movements, where the proximal joint reaches peak angular velocity first; followed by the distal joints reaching peak angular velocity later.


That is a whole lot of information for this article, but what does that all mean?


    In much simpler terms, most of the experienced basketball players follow a basic pattern of joint motion, joint velocities and joint postures at the release of the basketball. Besides what was already mentioned, it seems that all these good basketball players followed a similar order of joint movement and motion in order to develop more power when making the shot. It is suggested that this power to make the shot was generated mainly under precise control from the core and lower body, and then transmitted to the limbs which is finally transmitted to the ball when the shot is made (Martin, n.d.). For those who do not make the shot, it doesn't mean they made a mistake at making their angular velocity higher or any of the factors stated above. It is actually much more complicated as it could involve much more factors than just the angular velocity; possible reasons as to why they cannot make the shot could be related to the joint structure and other physical factors such as flexibility and strength.

    A study done by University of Manitoba took a closer look to how to make a free throw in terms of body movement and motion. As it has been pointed out by the study, a typical free throw shot will require the bending of the knees at about ninety degrees and a trunk flexion close to fifty degrees. The flexion of the trunk is important because it allows for the loading of the legs, which gives more power and accuracy to the shot as the trunk is extended. When the player sets up for a free throw, the flexion of the trunk, knees and hips lower the center of gravity. The quadriceps and hamstring muscles are stretched and used to produce a powerful extension (Alexander, n.d.). When the ball is raised by shoulder flexion, the trunk will begin to extend and as this happens the knees will increase in their depth of flexion. Also during the shooting, the wrist is hyper extended when the ball is released which also contracts forcefully and produces backspin on the ball (Alexander, n.d.). Overall, the fluid motion of movements, from the hip extension, shoulder flexion, elbow extension and finally wrist flexion make up the basis of a free throw.


    The arc of a shot is also a big factor for free throw shooting. The amount of arc is related to the strength of the shooter. The higher the arch, the more strength it requires generating a maximum peak height and velocity. However some players may not be able to generate this strength and may result in the pushing of the basketball and instances where their wrist flexion and elbow extension happens at the same time (Alexander, n.d.).

    Unnecessary muscles that are not used in the free throw shot should not be contracted so as not to create tension and interfere with the form. The easiest way to control a shot is to use the least amount of energy and only use the muscles that are necessary for the shot.  

    Finally, for the last paper we have found an article analyzing the differences between the skillful shooters and the inexperienced in the terms of the elbow and the shoulder. It seems that the skillful shooter was able to control his mechanical techniques better when compared to the inexperienced shooter. To maintain this control, the shoulder angle of the skillful shooter seems to be the result of the momentum generated from his core and transferred throughout his upper body and out through the shoulder; on the other hand, the inexperienced shooter shot the ball with the force generated from the shoulder only. Inconsistency was also evident in the unskillful player's shot in terms of acceleration throughout the time they took the shot; this is due to the fact that the inexperienced shooter used up more shoulder joint in generating the same acceleration when looking at the elbow velocity difference. The Skillful player's velocity was well maximized before the release of the ball; this points to better involvement of the controlling the momentum that is transmitted through the elbow to the ball. By having control over the momentum throughout the shooting phase, the skillful player is able to have control over the displacement and the velocity of the ball after it leaves the shooter's hands (Westmark, Brondbo & Gatz, n.d.). After examining the video available. it is evident that the inexperienced player pushes the ball out, and thus result in a straight elbow by the time the ball leaves the hand. Conversely, the skillful shooter launches the ball in a projectile manner almost like a catapult firing, resulting in the ball leaving the hand before the elbow is straightened; this creates a more controlled arc when the ball is traveling in the air. This article had also stated that the more optimal angle of shooting for a free throw is between both the experienced and inexperienced is around fifty-two and fifty-five degrees (Westmark, Brondbo & Gatz, n.d.). 




Group Huddle guys!

Disscussion


     Based on the results from the players and their peak angular velocities, we have concluded that the players who had more successful shots tend to follow a pattern of motion from the upper and lower body segments. Starting at the proximal joints and making its way to the distal joints - the shoulder to the wrist. (Martin & Bradley, n.d.)
When the player is about to take the free throw, they will start by a concentric contraction of the bottom segment of the body - flexion of the hip then followed by the knee and ankle. As the player is performing the concentric contraction, 

      The successful shooters followed a short-lengthening cycle. The bending of the knees and lowering of their center of gravity posed to create a short cycle where they were able to load energy from the lower body and lengthen to transfer the energy to the upper body in one fluid motion.  (Martin & Bradley, n.d.)

     The experiment shows that the players who made the shot tend to have higher peak angular velocity for the lower body segment compared to the players who missed. (Martin & Bradley, n.d.) The players who missed were shown to have a higher peak angular velocity in the upper portion of their body. This is because the players who had a higher peak angular velocity for their lower body segment are able to transfer energy from the lower body to the upper body resulting in a more accurate free throw. (Martin & Bradley, n.d.) In other words, upper body and limbs were used as a way to guide the ball while the power was generated from the lower body; results of this is higher angular velocity for the lower body segment. On the other hand, if the shooter generated more power from the upper body, the limb looses its ability to accurately guide the ball through the whole free throw motion. Another way of thinking about this whole free throw motion is that with the bending of the knee joint and hip joint, it creates a much smoother transition for the body when shooter shoots the ball. If the knee and hip joint doesn't follow the this smooth motion, more energy would be needed to generated the same power to shoot the ball and less consistency for the shooter to make the shot.  (Martin & Bradley, n.d.) Like we talked about before in the results section, the best shooter tend to have more controlled and consistent joint velocity when making the shot, and this controlled and consistent joint velocity contributed to the accuracy of the shot. In essence, those who succeeds in free throw are those who uses lower body to generates the force needed for the free throw. Because of this, expert shooters don't need to generate as much force from the shoulder, and can therefore can control the momentum better as it is transfered through the core of the body to the shoulder and finally to the ball. (Westmark, Brondbo & Gatz, n.d.)

     But what can we take from this? Although it varies between individuals, perfect shots still involves similar if not the same movement of the joints among different shooters, but those who start their shooting motion from their legs tend to have better  and more accurate shots.
    In another words, to make the shot perfect, player's arm must follow a few certain steps as outlined by the Manitoba study.
   
    First, when we take a look at the player's muscle groups, we see that the lower body of the muscle produced most of the power needed for a shot. This power extension is made possible through the stretch reflex and elastic storage from the muscles. (Alexander, n.d.) Also, the elbow should be kept directly under the ball during elbow extension to ensure that the ball is pushed in a upward trajectory towards the hoop. A common mistake while shooting is to elbow extend and shoulder flex at the same time, this will combine the energy contribution from elbow extension and shoulder flexion. Instead you want a uniform motion where all the joints are contributing by adding their forces. (Alexander, n.d.)

    As the ball is being shot the eyes of the shooter should be focused on where the player wants the ball to go and in this case it will be the hoop. A good basketball free throw shooter should release with a forward flick from the wrist and thus produce a backspin. (Alexander, n.d.) Since the force from the fingers is applied to the outside of the ball during release, this will ultimately create the backspin on the ball as well as traject the ball upward and forward. Also an important thing to note, when the wrist is flexed and the ball is released, the lower arm is pronating. This is very important for the backspin because it will help stabilize the flight of the ball and also keep the ball  spinning in a sagittal plane and ensures that no side-spin is acted upon the ball. Side spin would most likely occur if the lower arm moves in supination. To have no back spin would require the wrist and hand movements to have started before the elbow moves which then the ball would float through the air. (Alexander, n.d.) In terms of shoulder joint, the shooter should be flexing their shoulder while almost be pointing vertically to the ceiling. This will ensure that maximum vertical peak velocity is used on the ball. The wrist flexion is the final factor that affects the ball as it is released, it will control the angle at where the ball is released from the fingers and how fast the ball travels. If it is released too early or late, the ball will not be at peak velocity.

    But what about the other hand that isn't shooting the ball? The non-shooting hand should be placed away from the center on the side of the ball. This will help with the lining up of the ball to the hoop for better accuracy. (Alexander, n.d.) The elbow of the non-shooting arm should not be pointed outwards because then the non-shooting arm would be pushing the ball creating a force from the side of the ball. Rather, it should align with the shooting arm in a straight line with the wrist and hand. (Alexander, n.d.) The non-shooting hand should also be removed before the release of the ball, so that the shot has complete control from the shooter. The reason why the non-shooting hand does get released at the same instant as the wrists launches the ball is because it would direct unwanted side spin. It would be very difficult if the non-shooting hand was not used or positioned properly. If the non-shooting hand is not used it would be very tough for the player to bring the ball up from the knee and hip flexion. (Alexander, n.d.)

    The final part of a free throw is the “follow through”. (Alexander, n.d.) This is when the position of the joints continues to move in unison to their full range of motion and finally the release of the ball. A proper follow through has the trunk in a vertical position, ankles plantarflexed, legs extended, elbow extended, and the wrist and shoulder flexed. (Alexander, n.d.) A follow through is important because if the joints did not move in a full range of motion and fluidity, then it would decrease the velocity when the ball is released. A follow through will provide the shooter with great momentum and force to shoot the ball with optimal velocity and greater success at scoring.

Videos of Shooting forms (Westmark, Brondbo, & Gatz, n.d.)


 
Novice shooting form

 
Expert shooting form

The Buzzer beater

Conclusion

    Like many other sports out there, basketball does not follow one set of movement for all its plays. Some people shoots differently but accurately, while other people shoots with perfect form but just can't get it in the basket. What we can draw from this is that no one shoots the same way, but to make things easier for beginners, people have created guidelines for them to follow. However, like all sports, practice makes perfect; one can't solely rely on knowledge to be great at basketball. Guess its time for us to stop writing, leave our computers and go outside to practice those shots! 


Finally! Cue the scrolling ending credits

Reference

Martin, J. & Bradley, M. (n.d.). Biomechanical Analysis of Basketball Free Throw Shooting. Rx-Movement. Retrieved March 30, 2013, from http://www.rx-movement.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/basketballstudy.pdf


Alexander, M. (n.d.). Mechanics of Basketball Free Throw. University of Manitoba. Retrieved March 30, 2013, from http://umanitoba.ca/faculties/kinrec/research/media/free_throw.pdf


Westmark, K., Brondbo, O., & Gatz, R. (n.d.). Biomechanics of Basketball Free-Throw Shot. Concordia College. Retrieved March 30, 2013, from wwwwin.cord.edu/gzlarson/academic/10sg4/